Most business owners who regret their PEO choice made the same mistake: they evaluated based on the sales presentation rather than on the underlying agreement. The proposal looks good. The demo is smooth. The account rep seems sharp. Then 18 months later the service has degraded, the pricing has drifted, and the exit feels harder than expected.
This checklist is built from what experienced advisors review when evaluating a PEO proposal. It covers the five areas that matter most: pricing, benefits, workers comp, service model, and contract terms. Work through it before you sign anything.
How to use this list: Go through it with the PEO's proposal in front of you. For every item where you cannot find a clear answer in the proposal or the service agreement, ask directly — in writing — before signing. Vague or evasive answers are information.
Section 1: Pricing and Fees
Calculate the total monthly admin cost divided by headcount. Include all line-item fees — not just the headline rate. Some proposals lead with a low PEPM and add fees for payroll processing, off-cycle runs, or compliance services.
Benchmark: $100–$250 PEPM for most SMBsAsk for this in writing. Without a cap, your admin fee can increase significantly at each renewal. Three to five percent per year is reasonable. Uncapped increases are a yellow flag.
Red flag: No cap on renewal pricingSome PEOs charge $500–$2,000 to set up your account. These are often waived entirely, particularly when working with an advisor. Always ask.
Bonus runs, final paychecks, corrections. Some PEOs charge $50–$200 per off-cycle payroll. For companies with frequent exceptions, this adds up.
Section 2: Benefits
Request the specific plan documents — not a summary sheet — for health, dental, and vision options available in your employees' locations. Carrier networks vary dramatically by geography. A PEO with excellent plans in one region may have limited options in another.
Red flag: Cannot show actual plan documents before signingAsk specifically: is renewal pricing based on the PEO's aggregate claims pool, or is it experience-rated to your group's specific claims? If your group has a bad year, will your rates reflect it? The answer materially affects the long-term economics of the arrangement.
Ideal: Pooled experience — your group's claims do not directly drive renewalEmployees need to know their FSA grace period and run-out window. Confirm the deadline for submitting claims after plan year end — typically 30-90 days. On exit, confirm the post-termination claims window.
Request the fund menu and expense ratios. Some PEO retirement plans have limited investment options or charge plan-level fees that are not immediately visible. Compare these against what your employees could access in a standalone plan.
Section 3: Workers Compensation
Get the specific rate for your class codes before signing. For companies with physical risk exposure, this is often the most important financial variable in the entire evaluation.
Compare this rate against your current policy and market alternativesUnder the PEO's master policy, your claims may be pooled with other clients — or they may be experience-rated specifically to your account. Ask explicitly: if we have a significant claim this year, does that directly affect our renewal rate?
Red flag: Your claims directly drive your renewal rate without any pooling protectionSection 4: Service Model
The person presenting during sales is often not the person who will actually manage your account. Ask for the name and title of your dedicated HR Business Partner and ask how many clients they manage. Best practice is 30-50 clients. If the answer is significantly higher, service will reflect that.
Red flag: No named contact committed before signingGet this in writing as a service level commitment. For urgent employment matters, 24-hour response is the baseline. For routine questions, 48-72 hours. If the PEO is not willing to put response time commitments in the agreement, ask why.
Section 5: Contract Terms and Exit Provisions
Most PEO contracts require 60-90 days written notice. Some require 90-120 days. Know this number before you sign — it determines your minimum planning window for any future exit.
Standard: 60-90 days. Longer than 90 is worth pushing back on.You need employee records, payroll history, benefits enrollment history, and workers comp claims data when you leave. Ask specifically what format this data comes in and whether it is compatible with major payroll systems. Some PEOs deliver data in proprietary formats that require significant work to migrate.
Red flag: Vague or evasive answer about data portabilitySome PEOs charge $1,000–$5,000 in deconversion fees. These are negotiable — both before signing and at exit. Get the exit fee structure in the contract before you sign. If there is no exit fee, get that confirmed in writing as well.
What to do with red flags
If you encounter red flags in any of these areas, you have three options: push back and negotiate, request clarification until you have a satisfactory written answer, or walk away from the provider. A PEO that cannot answer these questions clearly before you sign will not answer them more clearly after.
The most important thing about this checklist: it is most useful when you have multiple proposals to compare against. One set of answers tells you what one PEO is willing to commit to. Multiple sets of answers tell you what the market standard actually is — and which provider is being generous or evasive by comparison.
Want us to run through this checklist against a proposal you have received?
We review PEO proposals regularly and can tell you within 20 minutes what the numbers say, where the terms are aggressive, and what to push back on before signing.
Book a Free AssessmentRelated: How to choose a PEO · PEO pricing explained · PEO exit guide